Even after the intricate behind-the-scenes planning – from crafting a dense and proper zigzag murder mystery to mapping out character arcs and motivations for stars Steve Martin, Martin Short and Selena Complicated and funny Gomez – went into Hulu’s There are only murders in the buildingHost John Hoffman realized he had to keep looking for inspiration in the moment.
He recalls Martin’s pitch, 75, a physically challenging comedy in the 10th episode of the first season. With the expectation that there might be a limit to his enthusiasm, he was surprised and delighted when his series co-creator immediately announced that he had joined, giving a series of new ideas for further development, following the same vein as the great passages of business that distinguished his early works.
“He started showing me various things he could do and play with, and I asked, ‘What more could you ask for?’ “Hoffman was surprised. After the first season amassed a devoted fan base, critical acclaim, and 17 Emmy Award nominations, Hoffman was particularly pleased to add an end-of-career bonus to the immense amount of goodwill. that Martin has created in his career. “He told me recently, just hopping around the room, he would never expect such a fun thing,” says Hoffman. “He said, ‘My career doesn’t have to mix a big, warm reception with a popular reception like this at the same time. My films will only be appreciated 20 years later. ‘ I didn’t think about it… I felt so touched when he mingled with everyone with that spirit to lead the way.”
Steve Martin is your hero. What’s fascinating about the way the two of you talk to each other when working together?
I was able to quickly get over all the scary elements of that, which would completely impede a creative mind, such as, “How am I going to make all the people That happy and see the way I want this to go?” I’ve had conversations with Steve about elevating the material beyond what can be really funny about it and finding its core humanity. I remember the big moment when I went to dinner at Steve’s apartment in San Remo in New York. I was terrified: Marty was there, and I talked to them and gave them this video that I found with the accompanying “Clair de Lune” where this incredible dancer was performing with a tarp springs and jumps up and down. After dinner, I pull up my laptop and I watch them see this whole piece. I said, “This idea fits the real art of the clown, but there’s bad things, there’s cynicism associated with it.” That’s what they’ve been doing all their careers, if you’ll be honest about it: elevate the art form. There are some leaps, there are some sweet notes that make us appreciate the unquoted stupidity they have given us over the years. I convinced them of what could happen in our first episode. They take some time. Like, “Wait a second – so this is going to be on the show?” And I said, “Yes. It shows where we want to hit the core emotions of these characters and explode – we do it.” They embraced it. I was so proud of that moment. because it made a huge leap, and it sent a very clear signal: This is not the program you expected.
Tell me about figuring out the characters’ arcs and developing a clever murder mystery while defining humorous rhythms and tonal shifts.
It’s easy to minimize what we’re doing with this half-hour comedy. Steve is a great mystery geek, and I’m not, so I know I have a huge mission here, and we’re keeping a lot of balls in the air. But that moved me. It feels like it’s all a piece of the puzzle to me, that you can put all of this together and keep it, and you’ll feel the ultimate relief and joy in this dramatic comedy. between these two while creating this mystery from the back to forward and twist our way to the end so that we can hopefully please the people who are there for that mystery, the sinners real offender or anyone who likes a good yarn. I went through a rather personal experience with a close friend from my childhood who was found murdered a year before I started developing this program. And, because I was disconnected from him, I spent that year investigating it in a way I never would. I went to Wisconsin, met his family, had to understand what led up to this moment. I’ve been obsessed with it, and I’ve never had that experience, but I want that to instill this as well. It all balances out the comedy, with the trio of people coming together and finding a connection out of great loneliness and isolation.
Steve and Marty form two of the great comedy partners of all time. How did Selena fit into that combination, and how did you create that alchemy with these three performers?
“Alchemy” is the perfect word. There’s only so much you can do as a writer to make that kind of thing. The necessary miracle happened that none of us knew to expect, or could dream of as well as it worked, that’s when Selena Gomez [came in]. We had a Zoom reading board, the first time we heard the three of them read these lines together, two weeks before we started shooting, and it was like, “OK, this is where the show is going. .” She has her own sense of humor that is very honed and sharp. She arrives with insight into Mabel’s backstory and the growing interest a millennial like hers would have in confronting these two maniacs like this uncle. After that Zoom, we all hung up and the phone line started to light up: Steve and Marty called and they said, “She’s perfect.” Both are not properly stabilized as characters and are unbalanced by her.
You’ve set foot in the comedy district how will you function?
The organizing principle in my thinking for the melody and comedy on this show is “New York City.” New York Takes It All: You can have something incredibly dramatic happen when you walk out of your building in New York that makes you deeply upset and anxious, and you have people who are wrapped up in each other that you never even knew before are people who are going through something as a unit. Once we squared off on the tune of the show being New York City, you can have your cake and eat it with these comedic geniuses. What if the cat is in the freezer? You can play a scene where Steve Martin discovers a cat in the freezer and has to pull it out and one of the legs is broken and now he’s putting it in his pocket. But that scene has to marry something deeply grounded: Then he meets Oliver in a very low-key moment, where he’ll sell the valuable poster of his heaviest defeat. her on Broadway. It’s an absurdist, but both of these are celebrated at the same time. It all has to be good and give the audience what they want, but it has to be fundamentally true to the story we’re building. That’s the joy of this show: It can go in so many different directions, and you never know where it’s going from one moment to the next.
The edited interview is long and clear.
This story first appeared in the August issue of The Hollywood Reporter.